Okay, this is me with a migraine, so adjust your expectations of coherence accordingly downward.
Over at Tbogg's place the other day, Michelle Malkin was mentioned. As always, someone decided to make the apparently obligatory ping pong joke, because that kind of thing always gets a laugh. We've all seen it. We've also all seen what happens when someone calls the person on it. There's an entertaining range of responses. I'm going to go on about a few of my favorites, by no means all represented at the link in question, but I'm guessing we've all had the opportunity to spot them elsewhere. Really, if you haven't seen the defensive reactions by the witty jokers it probably has more to do with an unwillingness on the part of the rest of the commenters to call them on it, since there's no shortage of the ping pong jokes themselves.
My favorite reaction will always be: I'm just doing it because it gets a rise out of her.
I'm not sure how you can interpret that in any way other than: I'm being offensive to offend her. I'm being provocative to get a reaction.
And if you're doing that, you should probably be aware that you will be, you know, offending people. And not just the person you meant to offend, since the jokes are based on broad generalizations in this case involving race and gender. Lots of people share the woman's race and gender, and they may be offended. This is not the smart bomb of snark. There will be collateral damage. And those people you've sideswiped may tend to be angry at you and attempt to retaliate, just to stretch a metaphor. If you make sexist jokes, you create angry women.
But that's okay, because then you get to use a selection of other responses. The most obvious being "You women are too emotional and serious. Lighten up." This isn't necessarily a second-tier response, you can use it as your first reaction to being told you're being offensive. It's probably the gold standard of rhetorical defense when you have offended. "Lighten up" can be said to women who think your comment was sexist, to ethnic minorities who think your comment was racist, to gays who think your comment was homophobic, to liberals who think your comment was eliminationist, etc. It's your basic multi-tool.
You can also launch into "You're trying to censor me, you fascist." Molly Ivins once noted that there was no one quite so self-righteously angry as a privileged class that fears it's about to lose that privilege. I suspect this can be applied to members of a majority who feel their right to offend the minority is being called into question as well. It's certainly popular among those who feel their god disapproves of what you're doing with your genitals. "Gays are trying to outlaw Christianity with hate crime laws!" Well, no. But it sounds a lot better and gets you more sympathy than "They object to my saying offensive things!"
The funny thing is, rather than trying to censor these people, I've noticed a tendency to just ignore it. They're trolls, it's what you do. You ignore them. And if you don't ignore them, they go into full-on defensive Lighten Up, You Fascist Over-Emotional Feminist Bitches, We're Only Doing It To Be Funny And Get A Reaction Out Of A Skank Anyway mode. You're not going to change their minds. You're not going to shut them up (if anything, quite the opposite). You're not going to shame them into knocking it the hell off. You are, in fact, going to have no effect except to transfer their animosity to you. And who needs that? We all know this will happen, and people who speak up do so in spite of knowing that, rather than, as portrayed, simply because they are hypersensitive killjoys unnecessarily leaping all over people who are just trying to be funny.
So most of the time, nobody bothers to point out that these people are being assholes. Which is a shame, because they could use it. So every once in a while, and by no means often enough, I feel compelled to support one of these brave people, even though I really do hate getting my insecure, undermedicated self flamed. And then you get told to lighten up, you fascist, and the next time you see the whole thing happen again, you probably keep your mouth shut. Which, really, may very well be the point.
Seriously. If the worst thing you can come up with to say about Michelle Malkin is that goddamned ping pong crack, you are lazy. Lazy, and unimaginative, and you may even be giving people the impression that you more or less agree with the offensive things she says, since you have made no attempt to challenge them.
And regardless of whether we will ever change their behavior, I can't help thinking that people who routinely say offensive things for the sake of offending should not remain unchallenged every time. I'm guessing that if, every time someone did this, we all piled on with "You're being a creep", it would happen less often. That's the same tactic that often keeps us quiet when we see it, after all. But I personally can't blame people for not wanting to spend all their time being slapped at by creeps for pointing out that they're creeps. And if you let them have the last word, it reinforces for them that they're very clever, and they'll do it again, and there's really no way not to let them have the last word. I'm unemployed and insomniac and I haven't got the time to spend arguing with them until they get tired of it.
So it really is easier to ignore them. And there's very little to be gained by not ignoring them. But I just can't shake off this belief that once in a while, someone does need to tell them we don't approve, and I'm grateful to the people who do stick their necks out there now and again, and will try to support them a little more often.
Sunday, April 29, 2007
Saturday, April 28, 2007
If you haven't already...
Go read this. No, really. Go read it. If you'd like to come back here and discuss it after, you are welcome to do so. But do yourself a favor and at least read it. Because I know it annoys me to just get links with no clue, a brief summary: It's a post at The Phil Nugent Experience--and some day I will figure out how to leave trackbacks--about guns, and war, and how humans respond.
Oh, and please don't go after that first commenter. We're all assholes on occasion, and probably should be forgiven as long as it's isolated incidents and not a lifestyle choice.
Oh, and please don't go after that first commenter. We're all assholes on occasion, and probably should be forgiven as long as it's isolated incidents and not a lifestyle choice.
Monday, April 16, 2007
The Power Of Positive Jerks
No, this isn't about Imus.
I read this a couple days ago, and have been thinking about how to approach it. Not the actual article there, but the book the column is about. This would be The Secret, that stupid book that apparently Oprah and others have been going on about. The author is one Rhonda Byrne, and upon finding out she's a reality TV producer, that really should be all we need to ever hear about this. Maybe you can't judge a book by its cover, but you sure ought to be able to judge it by its author.
Now, I'm going to bitch about the book without having read it, which is bad form, but let me excuse myself by telling a little story. During my first and only year of college, a lot of stuff I had managed to pretend wasn't anything to do with me suddenly became unpleasantly relevant, and this coincided, as college often does, with both a lack of health insurance and a glut of really good used bookstores. The net result of this was that I decided I could learn my way around my problems, and started in on the self-help books. I got lucky with my first pick and started learning stuff right away that, if it didn't solve my problems, gave me some hope that this was at least possible, and I dived right in. Soon my room was buried under piles of self help books, and after several months of this a bookstore owner gave me what was some of the best advice I've heard so far.
"You know," said a woman who didn't know my name but based on my buying patterns probably by then knew more about me than approximately eighty percent of the people I'd ever slept with, "maybe some people can't really help themselves by themselves."
I don't know if she expected me to get angry at her, though again based on what she knew about me from what I read she probably just expected me to slink away quietly and never come back, costing herself business. In any event, I wasn't angry, more startled, and in the years since, whenever I refill an antidepressant medication or a schizophrenia medication or a migraine medication, I am grateful to her for taking that risk. (I did continue to shop there.)
She's right. Sometimes self-help won't work. A lot of the time, in fact. Positive thinking is probably the stupidest of the self-help fads. It won't get you out of debt. It won't make your spouse stop beating you. It won't make your headaches go away. It won't cure your drug habit. It won't stop pollution. It won't keep your boss from laying you off. It won't make your car work. It won't make your schizophrenia go away. It is not a substitute for education, medication, money, therapy, or a stable homelife.
So I'm not going to read the book, because if I did, I have a feeling I'd be hurling it at a window within twenty minutes, and then I'd be deeper in debt trying to get that fixed. How's that for positive thinking? (Actually, it's a different thing, called "knowing your limits".)
But I read this column anyway, by Johann Hari, because I tend to read a lot of what comes up at Common Dreams and while I may have moderated the self-help book habit, I still enjoy reading and, again, reading online means I can fold cranes while I do it without having to hold a book open.
And I still haven't really established how to comment on this book. After all, when confronted with theories like this:
“The Universe will start to rearrange itself to make it happen for you… If you see it in your mind, you’re going to hold it in your hand.”
and quotes like this:
“I would visualise a parking space exactly where I wanted it, and 95 per cent of the time it would be there for me and I would just pull right in."
what is there to say, really? Although of course one would clearly be delighted that people have this magnificent power to affect the universe and use it to find parking spaces. Really, if I believed this person or this theory, I would be outraged at the lack of humanity on display here, so it's a good thing I regard it as similar to attempts to levitate the Pentagon.
Hari is equally disgusted with all of this, pointing out that the biggest flaw with positive thinking is "it instinctively blames all the people who falter or fail in life for their own misfortune."
This is just one of the many dead-on points made by this article, and I won't quote it all, so please do read it if you've any interest at all on the broader subject of a society that blames its victims. This isn't just about self-help, an admittedly fringe topic, it's about dismissing people as unworthy of our help.
But because this is covered so well by Hari, I've elected to not go off on a rant about it but instead to just snark. To that end, allow me to quote just a couple more lines.
She urges her readers to shun their friends if they become sick, because “you are inviting illness if you are listening to people talking about their illness”. You shouldn’t even look at fat people because that lets “fat thoughts” into your mind. (If you already looked at my byline picture - too late, fatso.)
To echo Hari, it's too late for you, dear readers. You're going to be fat. You're probably also going to end up with annoying housemates and neurotic cats, and the people I know who tell me I give them headaches can now be said to have a point (though it's one I've never really disputed).
However, if it works in reverse as well, you can at least be consoled that you'll be getting a lot more sex just from hanging around my positive sex aura. You can probably use that to cheer yourself up after getting the bill for whatever you break after you read Hari's quote from The Secret's author about the only reason people are poor.
My advice, read it over linoleum with a raw egg in one hand. Believe me, you're gonna want to break something.
I read this a couple days ago, and have been thinking about how to approach it. Not the actual article there, but the book the column is about. This would be The Secret, that stupid book that apparently Oprah and others have been going on about. The author is one Rhonda Byrne, and upon finding out she's a reality TV producer, that really should be all we need to ever hear about this. Maybe you can't judge a book by its cover, but you sure ought to be able to judge it by its author.
Now, I'm going to bitch about the book without having read it, which is bad form, but let me excuse myself by telling a little story. During my first and only year of college, a lot of stuff I had managed to pretend wasn't anything to do with me suddenly became unpleasantly relevant, and this coincided, as college often does, with both a lack of health insurance and a glut of really good used bookstores. The net result of this was that I decided I could learn my way around my problems, and started in on the self-help books. I got lucky with my first pick and started learning stuff right away that, if it didn't solve my problems, gave me some hope that this was at least possible, and I dived right in. Soon my room was buried under piles of self help books, and after several months of this a bookstore owner gave me what was some of the best advice I've heard so far.
"You know," said a woman who didn't know my name but based on my buying patterns probably by then knew more about me than approximately eighty percent of the people I'd ever slept with, "maybe some people can't really help themselves by themselves."
I don't know if she expected me to get angry at her, though again based on what she knew about me from what I read she probably just expected me to slink away quietly and never come back, costing herself business. In any event, I wasn't angry, more startled, and in the years since, whenever I refill an antidepressant medication or a schizophrenia medication or a migraine medication, I am grateful to her for taking that risk. (I did continue to shop there.)
She's right. Sometimes self-help won't work. A lot of the time, in fact. Positive thinking is probably the stupidest of the self-help fads. It won't get you out of debt. It won't make your spouse stop beating you. It won't make your headaches go away. It won't cure your drug habit. It won't stop pollution. It won't keep your boss from laying you off. It won't make your car work. It won't make your schizophrenia go away. It is not a substitute for education, medication, money, therapy, or a stable homelife.
So I'm not going to read the book, because if I did, I have a feeling I'd be hurling it at a window within twenty minutes, and then I'd be deeper in debt trying to get that fixed. How's that for positive thinking? (Actually, it's a different thing, called "knowing your limits".)
But I read this column anyway, by Johann Hari, because I tend to read a lot of what comes up at Common Dreams and while I may have moderated the self-help book habit, I still enjoy reading and, again, reading online means I can fold cranes while I do it without having to hold a book open.
And I still haven't really established how to comment on this book. After all, when confronted with theories like this:
“The Universe will start to rearrange itself to make it happen for you… If you see it in your mind, you’re going to hold it in your hand.”
and quotes like this:
“I would visualise a parking space exactly where I wanted it, and 95 per cent of the time it would be there for me and I would just pull right in."
what is there to say, really? Although of course one would clearly be delighted that people have this magnificent power to affect the universe and use it to find parking spaces. Really, if I believed this person or this theory, I would be outraged at the lack of humanity on display here, so it's a good thing I regard it as similar to attempts to levitate the Pentagon.
Hari is equally disgusted with all of this, pointing out that the biggest flaw with positive thinking is "it instinctively blames all the people who falter or fail in life for their own misfortune."
This is just one of the many dead-on points made by this article, and I won't quote it all, so please do read it if you've any interest at all on the broader subject of a society that blames its victims. This isn't just about self-help, an admittedly fringe topic, it's about dismissing people as unworthy of our help.
But because this is covered so well by Hari, I've elected to not go off on a rant about it but instead to just snark. To that end, allow me to quote just a couple more lines.
She urges her readers to shun their friends if they become sick, because “you are inviting illness if you are listening to people talking about their illness”. You shouldn’t even look at fat people because that lets “fat thoughts” into your mind. (If you already looked at my byline picture - too late, fatso.)
To echo Hari, it's too late for you, dear readers. You're going to be fat. You're probably also going to end up with annoying housemates and neurotic cats, and the people I know who tell me I give them headaches can now be said to have a point (though it's one I've never really disputed).
However, if it works in reverse as well, you can at least be consoled that you'll be getting a lot more sex just from hanging around my positive sex aura. You can probably use that to cheer yourself up after getting the bill for whatever you break after you read Hari's quote from The Secret's author about the only reason people are poor.
My advice, read it over linoleum with a raw egg in one hand. Believe me, you're gonna want to break something.
Thursday, April 12, 2007
When That Third Strike Comes Out Of Nowhere
Anybody up for another Don Imus thing? I promise not to cry if you skip it. In fact, let me offer you something else to do: Go make fake paper sushi.
Okay, musing forward. Nothing especially coherent, no moral. Just some observations. You've been warned.
It's kind of an interesting thing to watch, though. I mean, Imus probably doesn't, sincerely doesn't, think he deserves all this. And in a way he's right. It's not the most important way, in the most important ways he's absolutely wrong.
But I'm sure he really doesn't think he's a bigot. I'm sure it's never crossed his mind that he might be racist. And not in the way that Confederate flag wavers don't think they're racist but just think they're defending their culture from the minorities the government is giving special privileges to. He probably just doesn't think he's a racist at all. He probably is convinced he likes black people and gets along with them fine.
Why? Because no one's ever told him this before, at least no one with the power or voice to make him listen. So I imagine he sees this all as hitting without warning, and I bet he thinks it's unfair. I know he's supposed to have said he saw this coming, but I bet he hadn't a few days ago. I bet when he said it it didn't even occur to him that there was anything particularly objectionable about it, he sure wouldn't have thought it would cost him his job.
And that's where he's sort of right about it being unfair. He's said this shit all along, and so have all his colleagues, and aside from screaming and yelling from the "special interest groups", which are almost by definition people nobody in power takes seriously, there's been no consequences to it.
So it probably never occurred to him that there ever would be, and now that there are, he might be wondering where the hell that came from? This isn't an argument for not treating these things as serious because we don't uniformly do that. Limbaugh getting a pass doesn't mean Imus should. Rather, Imus having to deal with the reaction to his behavior means that Limbaugh should as well, and Savage, and Beck, and all of the rest of them.
It also means maybe the rest of us need to take a fresh look at our own assumptions about ourselves. Am I a "good person"? Would anyone tell me if I wasn't? Or do I wake up one day and realize that what I assumed was a tolerable sort of low-level assholism has suddenly landed me in a lot of hot water and, not incidentally, hurt a lot of people I didn't really mean to hurt.
I suppose it's just a human thing, or maybe I just like to think so because I've already had more than a few of those moments. Where you go from them probably has something to do with whether you can look back and realize that you *did* have some warning, and whether you recognize that you should have seen it, or instead just blame others for not making you listen.
I don't know that I would say Imus is blaming others for what's happened, but he sure seems to be regarding himself as something of an innocent victim who was just having some fun.
Okay, musing forward. Nothing especially coherent, no moral. Just some observations. You've been warned.
It's kind of an interesting thing to watch, though. I mean, Imus probably doesn't, sincerely doesn't, think he deserves all this. And in a way he's right. It's not the most important way, in the most important ways he's absolutely wrong.
But I'm sure he really doesn't think he's a bigot. I'm sure it's never crossed his mind that he might be racist. And not in the way that Confederate flag wavers don't think they're racist but just think they're defending their culture from the minorities the government is giving special privileges to. He probably just doesn't think he's a racist at all. He probably is convinced he likes black people and gets along with them fine.
Why? Because no one's ever told him this before, at least no one with the power or voice to make him listen. So I imagine he sees this all as hitting without warning, and I bet he thinks it's unfair. I know he's supposed to have said he saw this coming, but I bet he hadn't a few days ago. I bet when he said it it didn't even occur to him that there was anything particularly objectionable about it, he sure wouldn't have thought it would cost him his job.
And that's where he's sort of right about it being unfair. He's said this shit all along, and so have all his colleagues, and aside from screaming and yelling from the "special interest groups", which are almost by definition people nobody in power takes seriously, there's been no consequences to it.
So it probably never occurred to him that there ever would be, and now that there are, he might be wondering where the hell that came from? This isn't an argument for not treating these things as serious because we don't uniformly do that. Limbaugh getting a pass doesn't mean Imus should. Rather, Imus having to deal with the reaction to his behavior means that Limbaugh should as well, and Savage, and Beck, and all of the rest of them.
It also means maybe the rest of us need to take a fresh look at our own assumptions about ourselves. Am I a "good person"? Would anyone tell me if I wasn't? Or do I wake up one day and realize that what I assumed was a tolerable sort of low-level assholism has suddenly landed me in a lot of hot water and, not incidentally, hurt a lot of people I didn't really mean to hurt.
I suppose it's just a human thing, or maybe I just like to think so because I've already had more than a few of those moments. Where you go from them probably has something to do with whether you can look back and realize that you *did* have some warning, and whether you recognize that you should have seen it, or instead just blame others for not making you listen.
I don't know that I would say Imus is blaming others for what's happened, but he sure seems to be regarding himself as something of an innocent victim who was just having some fun.
Monday, April 02, 2007
Need A Laugh?
Here, go read this and this. Fred at Slacktivist has been on a roll lately, and I highly recommend him to both of my readers here, on the off chance they're not reading him already.
I'm sure he'll be delighted at the marginal uptick in his pageviews...
I did promise a blogroll, didn't I. I'll work on that this week, though I'm having further dental work done this week also. I'm actually kind of looking forward to it, since the more time I spend on nitrous oxide, the less time I spend thinking about my migraine. Um, is this drug-seeking behavior, you suppose?
I'm sure he'll be delighted at the marginal uptick in his pageviews...
I did promise a blogroll, didn't I. I'll work on that this week, though I'm having further dental work done this week also. I'm actually kind of looking forward to it, since the more time I spend on nitrous oxide, the less time I spend thinking about my migraine. Um, is this drug-seeking behavior, you suppose?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)