Showing posts with label Elsewhere. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Elsewhere. Show all posts

Sunday, June 10, 2007

I Got Nothing, But Fortunately That's Just Me

Over at The Phil Nugent Experience, Phil, if I may call him Phil, has got some stuff to say, and he's thought-provoking and eloquent and stuff. He's not getting quite the careful reading out of me that he deserves, mostly because I have the sort of headache that makes thinking like reading an eye chart in a heavy fog.

My advice is to go read it yourself (Not the eye chart.), starting here, where he ponders the credulously paranoid bent in humanity, and moving onto here, where he takes up the matter of crimes and misdemeanors and ethical lapses, and going on to here, where he offers some extremely timely advice for the eukaryotes among us, and then, I dunno, just keep reading till you've finished everything in the archives. Also, his heds are worth it just for themselves.

Phil's one of those people I'm amazed doesn't seem to have a bigger audience, though I admit that's not a short list by any means. But he's also one of those people who doesn't seem to care all that much. Which is something I'd probably spend some time here attempting to sort out if I didn't have the aforementioned cotton-balls-in-my-brain headache. Instead, I'll just send over whatever I can in the way of my highly perceptive and articulate commenters who, and I realize this is the limiting factor, don't already read his blog.

Meanwhile, I'm going to do some more research into Atenolol, because my partner has banned sex until I get the zombie thing sorted out. Apparently, it can really throw off your timing if your partner is yelling at people you can't see. I am sympathetic, but of a mind to be ungracious about it.

Tuesday, June 05, 2007

Second Best

Over at World O'Crap, there's a discussion going on prompted by a post made by Ace of Spades, and I'm not linking there because I don't actually give the faintest fuck about him. It's the discussion at Wo'C that's got my interest, in particular the comments by Hysterical Woman and by Bill S., who has been an extraordinary voice in the wilderness on this issue for as long as I've known him.

In essence, California is now allowing conjugal visitation for prisoners who are gay. This seems like only common sense, to me. Regardless of what their system is, it should be applied to everyone.

This has prompted Ace of Spades to remark, in an incredibly callous manner:

"Eh, why not? They’ve been allowing involuntary shower-room gay conjugal visits for hundreds of years."

followed by the cute little joke,

They should stop calling it "prison" and start calling it "The Most Wonderful Place In The World."

Blogger Scott at Wo'C, and the commenters there, are justly appalled by this. Rape jokes are comprehensively revolting to begin with, but most people either understand that, or at least accept that other people will regard them as creeps for making them and keep it to themselves.

There are, it seems to me, a couple of distinct attitudes underlying a comment like Ace's. The obvious one is that people deserve what they get. This is a pretty standard view among conservatives and libertarians. If you're poor, it's because you haven't worked hard enough, rather than outsourcing or disability. If you're in prison, it's because you're guilty, nothing to do with selective enforcement of laws or a justice system that favors the wealthy. If the bologna you gave your family caused food poisoning, it's your fault for not cooking it first. The general assumption there is that luck plays very little role in how your life unfolds, or at least that you can overcome bad luck well enough to achieve as much success as those who started out with better circumstances.

So if you're in prison being raped, it's because you deserve it, and I'm not in prison being raped because I don't deserve it. So there's really no need for empathy, and no basis for it. I don't have to wonder what it would be like to be that person, because that person is fundamentally different from me. There is no circumstance under which I would need to be defended against this, so there's no need for me to defend anyone else from it. They're getting what they deserve, and I'm getting what I deserve, and why should anyone interfere with that?

Well, perhaps we should because people don't go to prison exclusively because they are guilty. There is no legitimate way to dispute the fact that innocent people go to prison, and even guilty people go to prison for crimes that are greater than those they actually committed. But that's easy--up until about six years ago, it wouldn't really have occurred to me that a significant portion of my fellow citizens would feel anything other than outrage for a wrongly-imprisoned innocent person. Now, of course, I know that a lot of my fellow citizens think it's perfectly acceptable to torture the innocent, but in general it takes a certain level of cruelty to feel no compassion for the wrongfully imprisoned.

What's harder is the notion that even the guilty, and even those guilty of truly vicious crimes, even those guilty of, for example, child rape and murder, have not been handed a sentence of rape, torture, and possible eventual death by disease. For whatever reason, this isn't a sentence we hand out, and it seems like we have an obligation, therefore, to make sure it doesn't happen. Even people who absolutely do deserve to be imprisoned are at the mercy of the society holding them captive, and when people are at your mercy there are rules about how it is acceptable to treat them. Rape as a routine feature of imprisonment is a human rights violation, and it is so for a reason.

As with torture, it's something we do not, or should not, sanction because of what it says about us, what it does to us, even more than what it does to our victims. I've been raped. I have no empathy for rapists. I don't even have much in the way of empathy for rapists who have been raped. There are some people I like to believe I could cheerfully kill, and over whose death and suffering I do not grieve. But to say, as some people do, that rapists deserve what's coming to them in prison, strikes me as a way of doing to them what they did to us, even if only by proxy. And having been a rape victim, I am not willing to be a rapist, even in a technical way.

I could say they deserve it, but I won't. Because all rapists think their victims deserve it, and will come up with any necessary justification to make it not their fault but that of their victims. And sanctioning prison rape as some sort of "Well, they should have known not to go there in the first place" bonus deterrent is not in any significant way different from "Well, she should have known not to go there in the first place".

The other underlying attitude I sense in Ace's comment is a view that homosexuality is not about love, or that rape is. I'm not going to guess at which one is in play there, and people far smarter than I have spent a lot of words trying to deal with the attitude that rape is a compliment paid by someone who finds you sexually attractive.

But there are an awful lot of otherwise well-meaning people, not to mention a lot of assholes, who don't seem able to understand that a sexual relationship they don't find appealing is, consent being present, equal to their own. There's a tendency to dehumanize anything that is not a straight relationship. A tendency to believe that since you could not personally be attracted to a specific type of person, nobody normal could.

So gay relationships are linked in the public mind with pedophilia, or bestiality, or when the Freepers really get going on the subject, chair-fucking. The conclusion there seems to be that at least one of the participants is not a real person, and that there couldn't possibly be any sort of genuine love there, but only a mental disorder that results in a pathological sexual attraction to dogs, or to children, or to teddy bears.

Needless to say, this is a horribly offensive thing to say to anyone about the people they love. Not just offensive to say that you are a pervert for loving them, but that they are not, somehow, fully human. Personally, I'd rather people called me a pervert than suggested my partner was the moral equivalent of a blow-up doll, but these statements inextricably do both, and are all the more cruel for it.

It is, nonetheless, a very common attitude. Gay sex isn't love. It's just a mental disorder. And therefore, is there really any difference between gay love and gay rape? You might think I'm going too far with that interpretation, but at least one of the "ex-gay" organizations explicitly makes the point that gay sex is mutual rape, and nothing to do with love even if the participants are delusional enough to think they love each other.

So as far as I can tell, that's what Ace is saying here. Not just "Ha! Suffering is funny!" but also "Rape, sex, what's the difference to a pervert anyway?" And I'd like to contend that in a world less founded on a complete lack of empathy towards other humans, that either of those views would not be acceptable.

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

History is Made by Stupid People

Phil Nugent had some thoughts on defunding the federal government this weekend, you are encouraged to read them. The man's an amazing ranter, and I mean that with absolute respect. But it sent me off on a tangent of my own, and about the time I realized that my comment was going to get truncated over at No More Mister Nice Blog's place, where Phil crossposted, I decided perhaps it'd be better over here where a smaller audience might mean no one points out my various and prominent flaws in logic. (Unless you feel like it, in which case, have at it.)

For some reason, I'm pro-government. Always have been. People who say things like "Government doesn't solve problems", or "Name one good thing the government's ever done", or "Capitalism can do that better" baffle the living hell out of me.

Give me a few minutes, and I could name at least three dozen government programs that are important enough they need doing but that capitalism isn't capable of, or interested in. Let's start with orphan drugs. People with rare diseases, for which drugs aren't available because any given company can make more manufacturing Cialis than something maybe a thousand or so people across the US take. Unless we're willing to just write these people off, telling them, well, yes, a cure exists, but you can't have it because there's not enough profit in making it, taxpayer subsidies seem like a good solution.

Rural electrification, there's another good one. No for-profit company is going to string wire all the way out to some tiny hamlet in the Ozarks for the sake of a few hundred people. For that matter, no for-profit hospital is going to spend much if any time treating the indigent in their ERs if they're not made to. For-profit schools is another good way to say "MacDonald's Training Academy", and no kid is going to learn literature or citizenship or art there. Anybody want to explore the concept of capitalistic fire departments? Remember, your non-covered neighbor's housefire can very quickly become yours, and even if the fire department saves your home, you'd have less damage if they put out the fire when it was still two houses away. Road building, police departments, prisons, the military, you want to see what happens when they go capitalistic, Iraq is rather instructive.

There's an awful lot of stuff I'm perfectly happy to pay taxes for so everybody can use, and so no one person or group controls how it gets used. If civil courts are replaced with the sort of arbitration my bank tells me is my only option if we have a disagreement, those of us who aren't hiring and paying the arbitrators will never see justice. If the roads are maintained by auto companies, you can just keep your bike in your garage. If Microsoft is the only source of funding for the local aquarium, you can expect to have to wait outside with the field trip kids while they hold their monthly employee banquet. When the Wall Street Journal gives PBS more money than anybody else, you can expect to see programming where some B-list columnist quizzes guests as to whether the economy is going "great" or "really great".

So government can absolutely solve problems, and paying taxes is how we have a government with an interest in and an ability to solve problems that are important, rather then just profitable. And right off the bat, I have an adversarial stance toward anyone who tells me smaller government is inherently better--which is not to say I'm any happier with those who propose that larger government is inherently better. It's not the size, as they tell us, it's what you do with it.

The thing is, I don't actually know anyone who goes around saying that big government is inherently good, unless you count the walking pathologies we've come to refer to as "authoritarians", and even they aren't really arguing for bigger government, just more powerful government. And even that only in certain, narrowly constrained areas (like, "any part of the law that will control the behavior of people who aren't me"). So when I find myself arguing about the appropriate role of government, it is almost exclusively with republicans, and usually with the drown-it-in-the-bathtub sort.

I will continue to contend that a big part of why we have Bush is that we let Clinton get away with pretending we had a "budget surplus". I know, I know, we really only did it because it made the GOP's Congressional witchhunters look bad to be going after a guy who accomplished the budget restraints they were never capable of, etc. I was never a huge fan of Clinton, and a couple of his noteworthy policies still strike me as unnecessarily vicious, which is not to say, as they do, that he might not be entertaining to have a beer with. But even so, I found myself defending him in conversations with people who still regard The Clenis as the Antichrist. And defending him frequently. I suspect it was probably pretty common for liberals to have a few policies with which they agreed with Clinton, and to defend him on that basis to people who thought calling Hillary a "dyke", Chelsea a "dog", and Bill a "scumbag" was the height of wit.

So the budget thing came in handy, especially to jab at republicans and conservatives who advocated balanced budget amendments all the while venerating Reagan. But it was pretty predictable the sort of problems that would come from letting it be framed as a surplus. Especially it should have been predictable after we got a good look at what Dubya had done in Texas, though surprisingly few people seemed to regard it as any sort of valid indicator of anything.

So we had this money that was theoretically unspoken for, and the GOP, as they do, announced that the government was stealing your money! More than it needed! Because that's what governments do! And it is only justice--justice, I say--to return it to the people from whom the government stole it! And thus the grand GOP experiment of bribing the voters with their own money--and never delivering anyway--brought us to Dubya, Worst President Ever.

The worst part of allowing him to bribe his way into the White House with that money is, it damned well was never a surplus in the first place. It was the money we'd promised to all sorts of people and programs that we cut during the Reagan/Bush years, and, yes, during the Clinton years as well. We took the money out of schoolkids' mouths, we took it away from health inspectors and teachers and hospitals and research and civil servants in all those boring but necessary positions.

The reason at the time was that we couldn't afford it, not with these huge budget deficits. So we cut right back to the bone all the social stuff that helps hold the country together, and when we had the money again, instead of going back to re-fund those programs, we pretended it was a surplus. We pretended, for example, that teachers were doing just fine on smaller classroom budgets, or that poor families had learned to go elsewhere for food, and that these were solutions that were workable for the long term.

Regardless of whether every poor family found a non-governmental solution (and I can promise you a lot of them didn't), it's pretty close to obscene to have pretended that if they weren't objecting loud enough for us to hear them, then there was no problem. (Meanwhile, we made damned sure they couldn't get anywhere near any sort of position from which to complain.)

But the minute people started referring to that as a "surplus", rather than "finally having the money to meet our obligations", the GOP candidates were all set up to start yelling about how we needed to give all that extra money back to "the people who paid it". (Or at least those whose major tax burden was income tax, which is not the case for most people.)

That was predictable. And it was predictable that a whole lot of idiots would buy into it. And now we have Bush, and we're struggling to meet even the already grotesquely inadequate budgets for our social programs--and will be doing that for the foreseeable future.

Life sucks, and sometimes you have to make choices. If Junior drives the family car into the neighbors' living room, maybe the family has to talk to the dentist about making smaller payments while they do something about the mess. But if it turns out the damage wasn't quite as much as it was expected to cost, the family doesn't continue to skip dental bills and instead buy a big screen TV with the money. They sure as hell don't triple Junior's allowance with the money they're keeping back from dental bills.

Personally, I've never for the life of me been able to imagine why we let the GOP control the government when they don't seem to understand what the point of it is. Phil's got me a little closer to understanding it, and it was worth the read just for that.

(The title of this post, for the record, is an Arrogant Worms song.)

Saturday, April 28, 2007

If you haven't already...

Go read this. No, really. Go read it. If you'd like to come back here and discuss it after, you are welcome to do so. But do yourself a favor and at least read it. Because I know it annoys me to just get links with no clue, a brief summary: It's a post at The Phil Nugent Experience--and some day I will figure out how to leave trackbacks--about guns, and war, and how humans respond.

Oh, and please don't go after that first commenter. We're all assholes on occasion, and probably should be forgiven as long as it's isolated incidents and not a lifestyle choice.

Monday, April 16, 2007

The Power Of Positive Jerks

No, this isn't about Imus.

I read
this a couple days ago, and have been thinking about how to approach it. Not the actual article there, but the book the column is about. This would be The Secret, that stupid book that apparently Oprah and others have been going on about. The author is one Rhonda Byrne, and upon finding out she's a reality TV producer, that really should be all we need to ever hear about this. Maybe you can't judge a book by its cover, but you sure ought to be able to judge it by its author.

Now, I'm going to bitch about the book without having read it, which is bad form, but let me excuse myself by telling a little story. During my first and only year of college, a lot of stuff I had managed to pretend wasn't anything to do with me suddenly became unpleasantly relevant, and this coincided, as college often does, with both a lack of health insurance and a glut of really good used bookstores. The net result of this was that I decided I could learn my way around my problems, and started in on the self-help books. I got lucky with my first pick and started learning stuff right away that, if it didn't solve my problems, gave me some hope that this was at least possible, and I dived right in. Soon my room was buried under piles of self help books, and after several months of this a bookstore owner gave me what was some of the best advice I've heard so far.

"You know," said a woman who didn't know my name but based on my buying patterns probably by then knew more about me than approximately eighty percent of the people I'd ever slept with, "maybe some people can't really help themselves by themselves."

I don't know if she expected me to get angry at her, though again based on what she knew about me from what I read she probably just expected me to slink away quietly and never come back, costing herself business. In any event, I wasn't angry, more startled, and in the years since, whenever I refill an antidepressant medication or a schizophrenia medication or a migraine medication, I am grateful to her for taking that risk. (I did continue to shop there.)

She's right. Sometimes self-help won't work. A lot of the time, in fact. Positive thinking is probably the stupidest of the self-help fads. It won't get you out of debt. It won't make your spouse stop beating you. It won't make your headaches go away. It won't cure your drug habit. It won't stop pollution. It won't keep your boss from laying you off. It won't make your car work. It won't make your schizophrenia go away. It is not a substitute for education, medication, money, therapy, or a stable homelife.

So I'm not going to read the book, because if I did, I have a feeling I'd be hurling it at a window within twenty minutes, and then I'd be deeper in debt trying to get that fixed. How's that for positive thinking? (Actually, it's a different thing, called "knowing your limits".)

But I read this column anyway, by Johann Hari, because I tend to read a lot of what comes up at Common Dreams and while I may have moderated the self-help book habit, I still enjoy reading and, again, reading online means I can fold cranes while I do it without having to hold a book open.

And I still haven't really established how to comment on this book. After all, when confronted with theories like this:

“The Universe will start to rearrange itself to make it happen for you… If you see it in your mind, you’re going to hold it in your hand.”

and quotes like this:

“I would visualise a parking space exactly where I wanted it, and 95 per cent of the time it would be there for me and I would just pull right in."

what is there to say, really? Although of course one would clearly be delighted that people have this magnificent power to affect the universe and use it to find parking spaces. Really, if I believed this person or this theory, I would be outraged at the lack of humanity on display here, so it's a good thing I regard it as similar to attempts to levitate the Pentagon.

Hari is equally disgusted with all of this, pointing out that the biggest flaw with positive thinking is "it instinctively blames all the people who falter or fail in life for their own misfortune."

This is just one of the many dead-on points made by this article, and I won't quote it all, so please do read it if you've any interest at all on the broader subject of a society that blames its victims. This isn't just about self-help, an admittedly fringe topic, it's about dismissing people as unworthy of our help.

But because this is covered so well by Hari, I've elected to not go off on a rant about it but instead to just snark. To that end, allow me to quote just a couple more lines.

She urges her readers to shun their friends if they become sick, because “you are inviting illness if you are listening to people talking about their illness”. You shouldn’t even look at fat people because that lets “fat thoughts” into your mind. (If you already looked at my byline picture - too late, fatso.)

To echo Hari, it's too late for you, dear readers. You're going to be fat. You're probably also going to end up with annoying housemates and neurotic cats, and the people I know who tell me I give them headaches can now be said to have a point (though it's one I've never really disputed).

However, if it works in reverse as well, you can at least be consoled that you'll be getting a lot more sex just from hanging around my positive sex aura. You can probably use that to cheer yourself up after getting the bill for whatever you break after you read Hari's quote from The Secret's author about the only reason people are poor.

My advice, read it over linoleum with a raw egg in one hand. Believe me, you're gonna want to break something.

Monday, April 02, 2007

Need A Laugh?

Here, go read this and this. Fred at Slacktivist has been on a roll lately, and I highly recommend him to both of my readers here, on the off chance they're not reading him already.

I'm sure he'll be delighted at the marginal uptick in his pageviews...

I did promise a blogroll, didn't I. I'll work on that this week, though I'm having further dental work done this week also. I'm actually kind of looking forward to it, since the more time I spend on nitrous oxide, the less time I spend thinking about my migraine. Um, is this drug-seeking behavior, you suppose?